Published November 21, 2009 10:54 am - ANDERSON — When it comes to hiring relatives, the City of Anderson has no limitations. The City Council has not passed an ordinance dealing with the practice, and a state government ethics policy that discourages nepotism does not extend to local governments. Few localities in Indiana have passed such ordinances.
City Hiring: Anderson has no law against nepotism
Michigan City recently passed ordinance
By Aleasha Sandley, Herald Bulletin Staff Writer
ANDERSON — When it comes to hiring relatives, the City of Anderson has no limitations.
The City Council has not passed an ordinance dealing with the practice, and a state government ethics policy that discourages nepotism does not extend to local governments.
Few localities in Indiana have passed such ordinances. One that has, Michigan City, enacted the law after debate between the mayor and council.
Michigan City Mayor Chuck Oberlie said the policy, passed last year, forbids department heads from hiring their own relatives. Exceptions are made for the city’s police and fire departments because their hiring is overseen by merit boards.
Oberlie had vetoed the original ethics policy based on wording that he said would violate the privacy of some employees. After the council made changes to the ordinance and passed it again, Oberlie signed it.
“The City Council and our office had had conversations about transparency and trying to remove scrutinies that result because of the perception,” Oberlie said.
City residents had complained after Michigan City officials hired a city worker’s relative, according to Oberlie.
In a city of 30,000, nepotism in City Hall was not uncommon, Oberlie said. Since the ethics policy passed, the city, battling budget deficits, hasn’t hired anyone.
“There has to be a transparency in the process,” he said. “I don’t want this ordinance to be used to make sure we don’t hire the best person. To me, it’s one of those unfortunate twists of what I would think is commonsense. Our ordinance is very practical, and it lays forth what I think is the right thing.”
State lets cities decide how to handle nepotism
Indiana’s ethics policy governs the hiring of state employees. The policy stipulates that state board members, commission members or department heads may not hire any of the following relatives for the same board, commission or department: father, mother, brother, sister, uncle, aunt, husband, wife, son, daughter, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, niece or nephew. The same relatives cannot be in a direct supervisory-subordinate working relationship.
“We have not really in the state of Indiana adopted a law strictly against nepotism on a local basis,” said state Sen. Tim Lanane, who also serves as the Anderson city attorney.
The General Assembly considered a nepotism policy last year for townships but did not pass the policy when the larger bill it was attached to failed.
“There were some situations where it looked like the practice was a little out of hand,” Lanane said. “It was not uncommon to hear about nepotism within a trustee’s office.”